Top 20 Luxury Hotels in The Hamptons - Sara Lind's Guide (2024)

Opened April 2023. Set in Greenport, 41 km from Splish Splash, Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows offers accommodation with free bikes, free private parking, a garden and a restaurant. With free WiFi, this 4-star hotel has a bar and a private beach area. Some units at the property feature a patio with a sea view. At the hotel, the rooms come with a wardrobe. Complete with a private bathroom fitted with a shower and free toiletries, all guest rooms at Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows have a flat-screen TV and air conditioning, and certain rooms also offer a terrace. At the accommodation all rooms include bed linen and towels. Guests at Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows will be able to enjoy activities in and around Greenport, like hiking and cycling. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 76 km from the hotel.

Hotel rating: 9.4 (amazing)

Rooms: 30

Stars: 4

Delightful property. Relaxing atmosphere. Good breakfast. Located in the Village of Amagansett, Town of East Hampton, The Roundtree, Amagansett features free bikes, garden, BBQ facilities, and free WiFi. Free Private Parking is available at the property. Guest rooms are equipped with air conditioning, a flat-screen TV with cable channels, a coffee machine, a shower, a hairdryer and a desk. At the hotel each room has a wardrobe and a private bathroom. Montauk is 18 km from The Roundtree, Amagansett, while East Hampton is 4.4 km away. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 89 km from the accommodation.

This cozy hotel is beautifully situated with a simply incredible backyard. Extremely elegant design!

Hotel rating: 9.6 (amazing)

Rooms: 14

Stars: 5

Elegant. Charming. Great views. Popular among couples. The Pridwin is a waterfront resort located on Shelter Island with 33 well-appointed guest rooms and 16 private cottages an all-American restaurant and lively lounge with water views a full service spa-scenic pool and seasonal activities for every age The Pridwin is designed for couples, friends and families traveling together. Explore the idyllic natural setting through hiking-boating and other outdoor activities before retreating to the comfort of our private suites and cottages. .

This charming seaside accommodation provides comfortable beds and great views. It has a pool, tennis courts, and upscale dining options. Activities like spa treatments and exploring the private beach are available.

Hotel rating: 8.9 (fabulous)

Rooms: 35

Stars: 4

🇺🇦 Also see our guide to lovely hotels in Ukraine - to visit when the war is over. Ukraine has many beautiful destinations. 🇺🇦

Stylish. Comfortable beds. Popular among women. Located 500 meters from the village of Montauk, this beachfront property features an outdoor oceanside pool with a sun terrace and a private beach area. Free Wi-Fi is offered. Light rooms decorated in soothing colors offer a dining area and a small refrigerator. Marram rooms and studios are air conditioned and have wood furniture. Walk along the beach to nearby Shadmoor State Park or surf at The Terrace. The property is a short walk to the stores, cafés, restaurants and bars. Montauk Lighthouse is 9.1 km away from the motel. Montauk Downs Golf and Recreation is 2.7 km away. we are screen free .

Hotel rating: 8.7 (fabulous)

Rooms: 11

Stars: 4

Charming. Hip. Superb interior design. Opened November 2021. The Shoals Suites & Slips is offering accommodation in Southold. This 4-star hotel has air-conditioned rooms with a private bathroom. Parking is free for guests, there is no extra charge. Montauk is 38 km from the hotel, while Mystic is 48 km from the property. Long Island MacArthur Airport is 66 km away.

The accommodation is a charming 4-star hotel. It has cozy rooms and a delicious breakfast. Situated on the marina, it provides stunning views and a calm atmosphere.

Hotel rating: 9.2 (superb)

Rooms: 19

Stars: 4

Unique. Charming. Great breakfast. Popular among couples. Set in Quogue, 39 km from East Hampton, The Quogue Club features air-conditioned rooms with free WiFi. Guests can enjoy the on-site bar. Free private parking is available on site. All rooms include a flat-screen TV with cable channels. The rooms include a private bathroom. For your comfort, you will find bathrobes, free toiletries and a hairdryer. You will find a 24-hour front desk at the property. Tennis or golf can be arranged through the partnership with Westhampton Racquet Club and Laurel Links Golf Club. The area is also popular for cycling. The hotel also offers free use of bicycles. Riverhead is 12 km from The Quogue Club, while Greenport is 38 km away.

The hotel has bicycles available for guests to use, and it is a picturesque and easy ride to the beach. There are also many nice touches making it feel homey and unpretentious.

Hotel rating: 9 (superb)

Rooms: 12

Stars: 5

Luxury Hotel. Superb breakfast. Bridgehampton Inn features a garden, shared lounge, a terrace and restaurant in Bridgehampton. With a bar, the 5-star hotel has air-conditioned rooms with free WiFi, each with a private bathroom. The property is allergy-free and is located 24 km from Montauk Point Lighthouse. Guest rooms at the hotel are equipped with a seating area and a flat-screen TV with cable channels. The rooms include a wardrobe. Second House Museum is 33 km from Bridgehampton Inn, while Hither Woods Preserve is 34 km away. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 72 km from the accommodation.

Hotel rating: 9 (superb)

Rooms: 12

Stars: 5

Resort. Located directly on the beach, Gurney’s Montauk offers year-round accommodation in Montauk, 13.4 km from Montauk Point Lighthouse. Free WiFi access is available. Featuring an ocean view, every room offers a flat-screen cable TV. Each room has a private bathroom with a hairdryer and free toiletries. There is a 24-hour front desk at Gurney’s Montauk, which also features a full-service spa with healing treatments and ocean-fed seawater pool, and sauna. There are five dining and drinking venues available. Hither Hills State Park is 3.7 km away from Gurney’s Montauk, while Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course is 6.9 km away.

A five-star resort with all amenities possible, including the outside fire pit and bar with comfortable lounging. The cafe in the lobby has unforgettable views.

Hotel rating: 8 (very good)

Rooms: 158

Stars: 5

Resort. Introducing a new chapter for a storied East End social club at the expansive Montauk Yacht Club, a luxury seaside resort & marina spanning 16 acres on Montauk’s Star Island. Situated on Lake Montauk & home to the Hamptons’ largest marina, the property holds eight decades of legacy—and this season will welcome a holistic refresh for the modern traveler, with operations & management led by the award-winning team behind Proper Hospitality. Across the resort, 107 stylish & spacious guest rooms and historic villas offer private patios & balconies, Lake Montauk views, and interior design bridging classic East Coast architecture, well-appointed details, and amenities that embrace the “barefoot luxury” lifestyle. Merging world-class hospitality, waterfront beauty, and outdoor adventure, new additions include acclaimed on-site dining from Ocean Club restaurant & bar; refreshed guest rooms & historic villas; and elevated, one-of-a-kind wellness offerings. The new Ocean Club restaurant & bar, an acclaimed St. Barth’s concept led by Chef Jarad McCarroll, will offer an exciting destination for elevated indoor-outdoor dining, gatherings, and events on the East End. With menus spotlighting just-caught seafood, local produce, and shareable fare cooked over a wood-and-coal fire, the spacious restaurant will feature an open concept kitchen framed by stunning waterfront views. Across the expansive property, elevated amenities cater to the immersive waterfront surroundings and access to natural beauty, including new wellness-focused offerings; state-of-the-art fitness equipment, an all-day takeaway café, three pools (1 indoor), indoor & outdoor bars, padel, tennis courts, a private beach, and 232 wet slips that can accommodate boats from small day cruisers to 300-foot superyachts. Altogether, Montauk Yacht Club offers a unique haven for global travelers, locals, and a wide-reaching community of boating enthusiasts—welcoming a new generation of guests to experience Montauk’s distinct legacy, waterfront adventure, and endless natural beauty.

Hotel rating: 8.3 (very good)

Rooms: 107

Stars: 4

Highly elegant. Romantic. Great location. Popular among couples. Situated in Greenport and with Splish Splash reachable within 41 km, The Menhaden Hotel features concierge services, allergy-free rooms, free bikes, free WiFi throughout the property and a terrace. Featuring a bar, this 4-star hotel has air-conditioned rooms with a private bathroom. The accommodation provides a 24-hour front desk and luggage storage space for guests. At the hotel, the rooms include a wardrobe. All rooms in The Menhaden Hotel are fitted with a flat-screen TV and free toiletries. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 76 km from the accommodation.

A beautiful boutique hotel that has a rooftop deck with fire pits, a coffee shop downstairs, a vibrant bar, and great-smelling body products! This is likely the most romantic, unique and authentic luxury hotel in The Hamptons. And it is one of the most popular luxury hotels in The Hamptons, among couples!

Hotel rating: 9.4 (amazing)

Rooms: 15

Stars: 4

Charming. Historic. Comfortable beds. Featuring an on-site restaurant and seasonal saltwater swimming pool, Baron's Cove is situated in Sag Harbor, New York. Free WiFi is accessible throughout the property and free private parking is available on site. Each guest room has a flat-screen cable TV and a refrigerator. The private bathrooms include bathrobes and free toiletries. Select rooms offer views of the sea or garden. Guests at Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor are greeted at the 24-hour front desk. Clothing, accessories, and refreshments are available at The Dock Shop. The dining room serves fresh American cuisine and is open daily for lunch and dinner. Breakfast and brunch are available on the weekend. Bike hire is available at this hotel and the area is popular for cycling. Mystic is 48 km from Baron's Cove, while Montauk is 29 km away.

Hotel rating: 8.5 (very good)

Rooms: 64

Stars: 4

Luxury Hotel. Historic property. Beautiful. Offering on-site spa services, Montauk Manor is located in Montauk, New York. The property features an outdoor swimming pool. Free Wi-Fi access is available. Air conditioning, cable TV and a seating area are included in each uniquely decorated room. There is also a full kitchen with a dishwasher and microwave. Private bathrooms are equipped with free toiletries. Guests at Montauk Manor can enjoy the spa and wellness centre and multiple tennis courts. Meeting facilities and luggage storage are also available. An array of activities can be enjoyed on site or in the surroundings, including horse riding and fishing. A complimentary electric car charge is available to guests. Kirk Park Beach is 2.9 km away from the hotel and Montauk Museum is 10.1 km away.

A beautiful Tudor-style mansion located on a hill just a few steps away from the Main Street of Montauk. The outdoor patio is gorgeous and well kept.

Hotel rating: 8.7 (fabulous)

Rooms: 96

Stars: 5

Luxury Hotel. Located in Bridgehampton, this hotel features a farm-to-table restaurant sourced from its own on-site farm. Guests are welcome use the property’s complimentary house vehicles, provided by Lexus. A flat-screen TV, an iPad, and a minibar are featured in each room at Topping Rose House, which also provides luxury bathrobes and Frette linens for its guests. A sitting area is included and the en suite bathroom comes with a hairdryer. A spa, an outdoor heated pool and a fitness centre are all featured on-site at Topping Rose House. Guests can marvel at the hotel’s curated art collection, or stay connected with free WiFi access. A complimentary shuttle to the beach and private beach passes are also offered. The on-site restaurant offers locally sourced ingredients and products from the hotel’s own one acre farm. Breakfast, lunch and dinner are served daily. The beach is just 4 km from the hotel. East Hampton Airport is 6 km away.

Hotel rating: 7.8 (pleasant)

Rooms: 22

Stars: 5

Very stylish. Relaxing atmosphere. Comfortable beds. Set in East Hampton, 1.8 km from Indian Wells Beach, Journey East Hampton offers accommodation with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free private parking, a garden and a shared lounge. Located around 1.8 km from Two Mile Hollow Beach, the hotel with free WiFi is also 11 km away from Montauk Point Lighthouse. The property is non-smoking and is located 1.8 km from Egypt Beach. At the hotel, all rooms are equipped with a wardrobe. Complete with a private bathroom equipped with a shower and free toiletries, the units at Journey East Hampton have a flat-screen TV and air conditioning, and some rooms come with a seating area. All guest rooms will provide guests with a fridge. Second House Museum is 20 km from the accommodation, while Hither Woods Preserve is 20 km away. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 85 km from Journey East Hampton.

A beautifully renovated motel with luxurious rooms, grounds, and a cozy fire pit. The heated pool is a great feature, especially during the winter!

Hotel rating: 7.9 (pleasant)

Rooms: 17

Stars: 4

Cool. Historic. Cosy rooms. Popular among couples. American Beech Hotel has free bikes, garden, a restaurant and bar in Greenport. This 4-star hotel offers free WiFi. The property is allergy-free and is situated 42 km from Splish Splash. At the hotel the rooms are fitted with air conditioning, a seating area, a flat-screen TV with cable channels, a safety deposit box and a private bathroom with a shower, free toiletries and a hairdryer. All rooms will provide guests with a wardrobe and a coffee machine. Guests at American Beech Hotel will be able to enjoy activities in and around Greenport, like cycling. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 77 km from the accommodation.

This boutique hotel has a great location in Greenport.

Hotel rating: 8.6 (fabulous)

Rooms: 12

Stars: 4

Cool. Great value. Popular among women. Located just off Route 27, The Montauk Beach House boasts an outdoor swimming pool, gift shop, café and snack bar. Free Wi-Fi access is available. A flat-screen cable TV is included in each air conditioned guest room. The private bathrooms are equipped with free toiletries. Select rooms have a pool view. Guests can relax poolside or enjoy co*cktails in the lounge. There is a DJ on-site every weekend. Clothing, beauty products and more are available in the gift shop. The Beach House in Montauk has a 24-hour front desk. A selection of small plates and sandwiches are available at the café and outdoor grill. Additional dining options including South Edison are located within walking distance. Camp Hero State Park is 7 km away and Hither Hills State Park is 9.3 km away.

This lovely hotel has a picturesque location close to the beach. The rooms are furnished with Restoration Hardware products.

Hotel rating: 8.3 (very good)

Rooms: 35

Stars: 5

Great value. Set on more than 5 acres of beautifully landscaped lawns, this Long Island hotel features a modern American restaurant with poolside service. Free summer transportation to Cooper’s Beach is available. Rooms at the Southampton Inn feature seashore themes and are equipped with free WiFi and cable TV. An in-room refrigerator and a work desk are included. Located on site, Claude's offers breakfast, brunch and dinner meals made from fresh, local ingredients. Summer meals are also served in the courtyard and dining room. Southampton Inn guests are welcome to enjoy the outdoor pool, tennis court and library. A games room and children’s play area offers video games, toys and board games. The Inn at Southampton is less than 4 km from Southampton Golf Course and less than 15 km from the Morton National Wildlife Refuge.

This hotel has great affordability.

Hotel rating: 8.4 (very good)

Rooms: 90

Stars: 4

Luxury Hotel. Great views. Great location. Located in Montauk, within 1.2 km of Gin Beach and 3.2 km of Fort Pond Bay Park, The Montauk Soundview provides accommodation with an outdoor swimming pool and free WiFi as well as free private parking for guests who drive. This 5-star hotel offers a private beach area and a concierge service. Certain units at the property include a terrace with a sea view. Some rooms will provide you with a kitchen with a fridge, a microwave and a stovetop. Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course is 3.5 km from the hotel, while Montauk Downs State Park is 3.5 km away. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 111 km from The Montauk Soundview.

Hotel rating: 8 (very good)

Rooms: 31

Stars: 5

Resort. Popular among women. This Montauk beachfront property is 10 minutes’ drive to the Montauk Point Lighthouse and is less than 1 mile from Montauk town centre. Hero Beach Club offers free WiFi throughout the property. There is an outdoor swimming pool and daily cleaning service for the rooms. In-room massage services can be arranged by the front desk. Each room has cable TV and a private entrance. Some of the rooms have a balcony or deck that offers a view of the ocean. Hero Beach Club is located 3 miles from Ditch Plains Surfing Beach. Fort Pond is less than 1 mile from the property and offers fishing. Fishing is also available at the Fort Pond Harbour which is only 5 minutes’ drive away.

A lovely hotel with a picnic area and heated pool on a fantastic property with a fire pit. Such an excellent choice for a family stay!

Hotel rating: 8.2 (very good)

Rooms: 22

Stars: 4

Trendy. Great value. Popular among women. Situated in Montauk, within 9.5 km of Gin Beach and 5.5 km of Theodore Roosevelt County Park, Haven Montauk provides accommodation with free bikes and a garden, and free WiFi. The bay is a 4-minutes' walk across the street from the property. All guest rooms in the hotel are fitted with a TV and a wardrobe. All rooms have a private bathroom, while some rooms include a kitchenette. Some rooms have a view of the ocean and some rooms have a view of Lake Montauk and the sunset. Haven Montauk offers a seasonal outdoor pool, a fire pit and a barbecue area. 3.4 km from Montauk Downs State Park, the property is also 8.8 km away from Montauk Point State Park. Montauk Racquet Club is 3.7 km away and Navy Park Road is 5 km from the hotel. Montauk train station is 3.2 km away and Block Island Ferry is 300 metres away.

Hotel rating: 8.5 (very good)

Rooms: 25

Stars: 4